The quest for adventure in the expansive universe of Starfield seldom seems to end. One significant decision players face is whether to replay the main quest in the New Game Plus mode. This guide aims to provide an in-depth analysis of the pros and cons associated with each choice, aiding you in making an informed decision.

Completing The Game

As you approach the end of Starfield’s main storyline, a pivotal choice looms. The main quest involves a significant subplot about The Unity, a mysterious and highly sought-after realm. Players are tasked with collecting artifacts and eventually siding with either The Hunter or The Emissary. Post your decision; the final battle ensues, culminating in your acquiring all the artifacts. You then have the option to travel to the void of The Unity. Here, the choice is simple yet profound: stay with the life you’ve built or proceed to become Starborn.

Pros and Cons of New Game Plus

Starting New Game Plus: The Advantages

Upon entering Unity, the game resets, but you emerge as a Starborn. The missions are similar, albeit more challenging. New dialogues unlock, and you have the possibility of leveling up infinitely. Notably, you:

  1. Gain Starborn-specific dialogue options.
  2. Face tougher missions and enemies.
  3. Retain your memories and stats.
  4. Get the chance to save everyone when areas like the Lodge and The Eye are under attack.
  5. Receive new gear and a ship as a Starborn.

Starting New Game Plus: The Drawbacks

Starting New Game Plus isn’t without its cons:

  1. You have to restart with no weapons or items.
  2. Emotional ties to characters, possibly including a spouse, are severed.
  3. The missions essentially remain the same, causing a sense of repetitiveness.

Pros and Cons of Continuing the Main Quest

Advantages of Staying in the Main Quest

If you opt not to transition into Unity, you can continue exploring and completing side missions. Among the benefits are:

  1. You retain your relationships.
  2. NPCs acknowledge your decision to stay.
  3. You avoid replaying missions.
  4. Gameplay is slightly easier than in New Game Plus.

Drawbacks of Staying in the Main Quest

However, there are downsides:

  1. You miss the opportunity to become Starborn.
  2. No access to Starborn-exclusive gear.
  3. Lingering guilt from any casualties during key battles like those at the Lodge or The Eye.

Making Your Decision: Main Story or New Game Plus?

The decision is inherently personal. You could opt for New Game Plus to explore new dialogue options and challenges. Alternatively, you may prefer the emotional continuity of the main story. Importantly, Unity remains accessible even if you choose to continue with the main quest. For those still on the fence, maintaining a separate save file before the Unity decision could offer a chance for experimentation.

Final Thoughts

The decision to enter New Game Plus or continue the main quest in Starfield is multifaceted. Each choice has its unique set of advantages and drawbacks. By assessing these factors, players can make a decision that enhances their gaming experience. The beauty of Starfield lies in its ability to offer a rich, branching narrative that accommodates various playstyles and decisions.

Also Read: