Chris Pine, known for his role as Captain James T. Kirk in the Star Trek reboot series, has shared his thoughts on the franchise’s future as fans eagerly await the fourth movie. Reflecting on the trilogy’s performance, Pine believes that the movies chased the wrong audience, leading to diminishing box office returns.

The Star Trek Trilogy: Success and Decline

The Star Trek trilogy, released by Paramount Plus, started strong with the 2009 reboot directed by J.J. Abrams. The first film grossed $257 million and received positive reviews. However, the sequels saw a decline in box office performance, with Star Trek Into Darkness (2013) earning $228 million and Star Trek Beyond (2016) only $158 million. Despite their critical success, the movies failed to maintain their financial momentum.

Chasing the Wrong Audience

During his appearance at the ACE Superhero Comic Con 2024, Pine discussed the issues that plagued the Star Trek movies. He felt that the studio’s focus on broadening the audience base was misguided. “It was always about getting the audience and building the audience,” Pine said, according to Popverse. He emphasized that the franchise should cater to its dedicated fanbase rather than trying to appeal to everyone.

Budget Issues and Unrealistic Expectations

Pine also highlighted the problem of escalating budgets. He noted that studios often overspend in the hopes of achieving massive box office returns. “It takes $500 million to produce a film that people like, and for it to be deemed successful, it had to make tons of money,” Pine explained. He argued that these metrics don’t make sense and suggested that smaller, story-driven films could be more successful and sustainable.

A New Approach for Star Trek 4

To revive the franchise, Pine proposed a shift in focus towards better storytelling and smaller budgets. “I think we just make a much smaller film that’s more story-driven, more character-based, there’s less shit exploding, and maybe do it that way,” he suggested. Pine also recommended shooting on film instead of digital to enhance the visual quality. This approach, he believes, would appeal to the core fanbase and potentially attract new viewers without the need for exorbitant budgets.

Historical Context and Financial Realities

The financial trajectory of the Star Trek movies underscores Pine’s points. The 2009 Star Trek had a $150 million budget and performed well at the box office. In contrast, Star Trek Beyond, with a $190 million budget, grossed significantly less. Even though it received an 86% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, its financial performance highlighted the risks of high-budget productions. Pine’s insights suggest that a return to more modest budgets could help balance quality and financial viability.

Conclusion

Chris Pine’s perspective on the future of Star Trek offers a compelling argument for a return to basics: focusing on storytelling, character development, and appealing to the franchise’s loyal fans. By reducing budgets and prioritizing narrative over spectacle, Paramount Plus could potentially revive the Star Trek series and deliver a film that satisfies both diehard Trekkies and new audiences alike.

Also Read: