The Evolution of Gaming Commentary
Tim Cain, a veteran RPG designer, recently shared his thoughts on how the rise of influencers has transformed gaming and game development. In a new video on his YouTube channel, he expressed concern about the impact of social media and video content on gamers' perspectives, noting a significant shift from the 1980s to today. The late '90s marked the start of a change in gaming tastes, as internet message boards began to replace the DIY ethos of relying on game manuals and print magazines like PC Gamer.
The Influence of Parasocial Relationships
According to Cain, the proliferation of video content and influencers has led to a troubling trend in how gamers form opinions about games. He stated, "More people seem to be abdicating their own judgement to that of people they see online." This reliance on influencers creates a disconnect where gamers no longer critically assess games but instead accept opinions handed to them. Cain elaborated, saying, "People don't form opinions from the online video, they're handed an opinion from the online channel they're watching." This shift raises questions about the quality of discourse surrounding games.
The Impact on Game Design
Cain is concerned about how these trends could affect game design itself. He suggested that developers might feel pressured to create games that cater to the preferences of influencers, stating, "It's probably not a healthy way of designing a game." The emphasis on what might make for good video clips can lead to a restriction of creativity and innovation. This shift from a freeform development environment to one constrained by consumer expectations and influencer opinions is alarming for someone who has witnessed the evolution of gaming over 32 years.
Looking Ahead
As for the future of gaming, Cain expressed uncertainty about what the 2030s will hold. He remarked, "I have no idea what the 2030s are going to be like." The potential for further entrenchment of influencer-driven opinions raises concerns about the overall health of the gaming community and its relationship with game design. As gamers navigate this landscape, the hope is for a conscious reaction against the current trends, fostering a more informed and critical community.