Tokyo District Court Archives

Nintendo and The Pokémon Company have officially filed a lawsuit against Pocketpair, the developer behind the hit game Palworld, for alleged infringement of patent rights. Known for its unique blend of survival mechanics and creature-catching gameplay, Palworld has often been described as "Pokémon with guns". However, it seems this comparison has landed the game in hot water, as Nintendo claims that Palworld’s designs and features infringe on the Pokémon franchise’s intellectual property. What Is Palworld? For those unfamiliar with Palworld, it’s a survival game that combines resource management and combat with a feature that resembles the monster-catching mechanics found in Pokémon. Players use balls to capture creatures—referred to as Pals—which are of different elemental types, similar to the Pokémon creatures. These Pals aid in battles and exploration, bringing an undeniable resemblance to the core Pokémon gameplay mechanics. From the outset, many critics and fans pointed out the visual and mechanical similarities between Palworld and Pokémon, raising concerns that Nintendo might take legal action. Now, roughly eight months after Palworld’s early access release, those predictions have come true. Nintendo’s Legal Action Against Pocketpair On September 18, Nintendo and The Pokémon Company officially filed a patent infringement lawsuit in Tokyo District Court against Pocketpair. The lawsuit seeks not only an injunction to stop further infringement but also compensation for damages incurred. According to the filed documents, the companies assert that Palworld infringes on multiple Pokémon-related patents. Nintendo stated that it is committed to protecting its intellectual property and will take all necessary actions to preserve its iconic brands and franchises, which they’ve built over the years. This lawsuit is seen as a significant move to protect the legacy of Pokémon and its distinct gameplay mechanics. Palworld’s Silence and Timing of the Lawsuit As of now, Pocketpair has not responded publicly to the lawsuit. In previous interviews, the developer had suggested that they hadn’t received any communication from Nintendo about the game’s similarities to Pokémon. However, Nintendo president Shuntaro Furukawa hinted back in February that the company would take legal action against those infringing on their intellectual property. It remains unclear why Nintendo waited eight months after Palworld’s early access release to file the lawsuit. However, the timing is particularly challenging for Pocketpair, as Palworld is rumored to have a significant presence at the Tokyo Game Show (TGS). Speculation suggests that a PlayStation port of Palworld, as well as the game’s 1.0 release, could be announced during the event. The lawsuit could throw these plans into jeopardy, potentially delaying key announcements. What This Means for Palworld Currently, Palworld is available on PC and Xbox in early access, and its popularity has been undeniable, with the game achieving financial success. However, the legal battle against two major entities—Nintendo and The Pokémon Company—will undoubtedly be expensive and resource-draining. Pocketpair now faces the difficult task of defending its game in court while also managing development and keeping its player base informed. The lawsuit’s outcome could have far-reaching consequences. Depending on the court’s ruling, existing versions of Palworld on PC and Xbox may be affected. The potential for future expansions or ports to platforms like PlayStation could also be delayed or altered if Nintendo’s claims are upheld. Final Thoughts Nintendo’s decision to file a lawsuit against Pocketpair underscores the importance of intellectual property protection in the gaming industry. While Palworld has been a creative success, its striking resemblance to Pokémon raises valid concerns about how far inspiration can go before it infringes on established IP. The lawsuit is likely to have significant implications not only for Pocketpair but for the game’s fans, many of whom are eagerly awaiting future updates and releases. As the case develops, it will be interesting to see how Pocketpair responds and what this means for Palworld’s future in the gaming world. Also Read:

Hi, I'm TheBadGamer

Tokyo District Court

Nintendo and Pokémon Sue Palworld Developer for Patent Infringement